This started it all and was sent out on 17 December 1996:
| 1. | Radiohead - The bends |
| 2. | The Red House Painters ^^ |
| 3. | Smashing Pumpkins - Mellon Collie & the Infinite Sadness |
| 4. | Rollerskate Skinny - Horsedrawn wishes |
| 5. | Yo La Tengo - Fakebook |
| 6. | Manic Street Preachers - Everything Must Go |
| 7. | Oasis - (What's the story) Morning Glory |
| 8. | Sparklehorse - VivaDixieSubmarineTransmissionPlot |
| 9. | Passengers - Original Soundtracks |
| 10. | Whipping Boy - Heartworm |
| 11. | Vic Chestnut - West of Rome |
| 12. | The Divine Comedy - Cassanova |
| 13. | Suede - Coming up |
| 14= | Pavement - Wowee Zowee |
| 14= | A House - I am the greatest |
| 16. | Beastie Boys - Ill Communication |
| 17. | Pulp - Different Class |
^^ votes were spread between 3 albums but I decided since RHP were so ubiquitous they should be placed here