home

Top 10 1998 #3

  1. Belle and Sebastian - The Boy With The Arab Strap
  2. Air - Moon Safari
  3. Massive Attack - Mezzanine
  4. Mercury Rev - Deserter's Songs
  5. Jeff Buckley - Sketches
  6. Billy Bragg and Wilco - Mermaid Avenue
  7. Mogwai - Young Team

Lists

Scott Balikian  Declan Bates  Enda Bates  Garbhán Blake  Gerard Cagney  Tom Corcoran  Brian Fenton  Martin Hayes  Lucas Hilbert  Niall Lynch  Kevin McGrath  Dave McGuinness  Ray McNamara  Breanndán Ó Nualláin  Caroline O'Reilly 

All time Contributors

Scott Balikian

1. Marc Olsen - Tunnel Songs
2. Mogwai - Young Team
3. Elliott Smith - Roman Candle
4. Jeff Buckley - Grace
5. Tom Waits - Blue Valentine
5. Mogwai - Kicking a Dead Pig
7. Lola Rennt - Soundtrack
8. Buena Vista Social Club
9. Gillian Welch - Revival
10. Boston - Boston (seriously. it's the only tape I have here in germany to listen to in my car)

top

Declan Bates

1. Music for Vespers - Rachmaninov/St. Petersburg Chamber Choir
2. Violin concertos - JS Bach/some old french chap
3. Beethovan/Busoni/Liszt recital - Evygeny Kissin
4. Strabat mater - Boccherini/38 quartet
5. The blue note - Martin Hayes
6. Chopin live at Carnagie Hall - Evygeny Kissin
7. Debussy preludes/Images/children's corner - Arturo Benedetti Michelangeli
8. Arvo Part - Tabula Rasa
9. 16 lovers lane - The Go Betweens
10. This is my truth tell me yours - Manic Street Preachers

top

Enda Bates

Heres me top ten, sorry about the two best ofs, but there I love 'em too much to leave out.
1. Adore - Smashing Pumpkins
2. The best of Nick Cave & the Bad Seeds - Nick Cave & the Bad Seeds.
3. Jeff Buckley - Sketchs
4. Bernard Butler - People Move On.
5. Unkle - Psyence Fiction.
6. The best of James - James
7. Mezzanine - Massive Attack.
8. Stereophonics - Word Gets Around.
9. James Iha - Let It Come Down.
10. Radiohead - Airbag/How am I driving.

top

Garbhán Blake

here it is, after very little deliberation, a rush through movie reviews last night in an attempt to remember what I had seen this year and many minutes spent racking my brains to recall the shows I'd seen, my Top Ten Lists are ……..

Albums:
1. Luna - Bewitched
2. Belle and Sebastian - The Boy With The Arab Strap
3. Wu Tang Killa Bees - The Swarm
4. Air - Moon Safari
5. Mercury Rev - Deserter's Songs
6. DJ Shadow - Preemptive Strike
7. Beastie Boys - Hello Nasty
8. Oasis - The Masterplan
9. Lee Dorsey - Yes We Can
10. Terry Hall - Laugh

Honourable Mentions:
Radiohead - The Bends
Gomez - Bring It On
Travis - Good Feeling
PJ Harvey - Is This Desire?
Gus Gus - Polydistortion
Billy Bragg and Wilco - Mermaid Avenue
Pulp - This is Hardcore
Jeff Buckley - Sketches For My Sweetheart The Drunk
Arnold - Hillside

Probably would have made if I had a few listens:
Spiritualized - Live at the Albert Hall
Beck - Mutations
Sparklehorse - Good Morning Spider
Vic Chesnutt - The Salesman and Bernadette

Compilation of the year:
Nick Cave - The Best of Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds
Live Shows:
1. Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds - The Metro, Chicago 13/9/1998.
2. Henry Rollins - The Modjeska, Milwaukee 22/10/1998.
3. Bleed - The Cactus Club, Milwaukee 7/11/1998.
4. PJ Harvey - The Vic, Chicago 28/10/1998.
5. Drugstore - Shank Hall, Milwaukee 19/7/1998.
6. Tricky - The Metro, Chicago 26/11/1998.
7. Milwaukee Brewers vs St. Louis Cardinals - County Stadium, Milwaukee 20/9/1998. *
8. Guinness Fleadh - Arlington Race Track, Arlington 20/6/1998.
9. Swervedriver - Shank Hall, Milwaukee 19/4/1998.
10. Bob Mould - The Rave, Milwaukee 16/9/1998.

*The game Mark McGuire hit his 65th home run of the season on his way to a record breaking 70. He actually had another homer in the same game ruled out for fan interference .

Movies: (More interesting compilation might have been what movies I have missed this year, rather than ones I've seen).
1. American History X
3. I Went Down
4. Sophie's Choice
5. The Butcher Boy
6. Pi
7. The Truman Show
8. The Big Lebowski
9. Saving Private Ryan
10. Pecker

top

Gerard Cagney

Here's my 1998 list. Nobody except Portishead produced their best stuff I think, and I haven't heard the Smashing Pumpkins album. Anyway:

1. Portishead - Portishead
2. Jesus and Mary Chain - munki
3. Massive Attack - Mezzanine
4. Luna - Pup Tent
5. Goldie - Saturn Returnz
6. Sonic Youth - A thousand leaves
7. Radiohead - Airbag
8. Billy Bragg/Wilco - Mermaid Avenue
9. Tricky - Angels with dirty faces
10. Propellarheads - Decks'n'drums'n'rock'n'roll
Hon Mens: there's too many of these, i can't decide…
Photek - Form & Function
Saint Etienne - Good humour
UNKLE - Psyence fiction
Katell Keineg - Jet
Mercury Rev - Deserter's Songs
Stereolab - Space age bachelor pad music
Maura O'Connell - Wandering home
Can - Sacrilage
..maybe REM, Up, I've only just got it, and 2 Best Ofs, Nick Cave and John Hiatt.

For what it's worth, Spiritualized/Radiohead at the Paramount in Seattle was the best live gig, I'll be lucky to see anything like it again.

top

Tom Corcoran

  1. Air - Moon Safari
  2. Wu Tang Killa Bees - The Swarm
  3. Mercury Rev - Deserter's Songs
  4. Unkle - Psyence Fiction
  5. Miles Davis - Panthalassa
  6. Amon Tobin - Permutation
  7. Massive Attack - Mezzanine
  8. Talvin Singh - Anokha: Sounds of the Asian underground
  9. Source Direct - Controlled Developments
  10. REM - Up
Honourable Mentions: Best Films
  1. Life is Beautiful
  2. The Truman Show
  3. Celebrity
  4. The Butcher Boy
  5. My name is Joe
  6. The sweet hereafter
  7. Pi
  8. The Big Lebowski
  9. Buffalo 66
  10. The Opposite of Sex
  11. Jackie Brown
  12. Pecker
Honourable Mentions Worst Films
  1. Titanic
  2. Armageddon
  3. The Siege
  4. Blade
Notable live events

top

Brian Fenton

I've tried to avoid a repeat performance of last year's Red House Painters rout, but to be honest I was hard pressed to come up with any albums of merit. You see, I'm a musical masochist in that I never give myself what I most desire. So, for example, I wanted to buy but never did the new David Gray, Sophia, Sparklehorse, Grant Lee Buffalo, Buffalo Tom, Pernice Brothers, Bedhead, REM, Divine Comedy etc etc albums. Instead I bought lots of old second hand stuff from years ago or earlier albums by people I already like.

There was also the sad truth that it was yet another miserable year for hoary old rockers and diehard technophobes like myself. I think we're reaching the end of our tether now. The new Mark Hollis was quite a disappointment, as were the new ones from Seam, Low and Gastr del Sol. Jeff Buckley scraped onto my list under the "well, he won't get another opportunity since he's dead, now will he?" ruling.

I'm actually quite glad Red House Painters' new album wasn't out in time to qualify for this list, because I'd probably have to exclude that too, if their miserable performance in Dublin was anything to go by. They wouldn't even get the job as a Thin Lizzy covers outfit. Ocean Beach is still my favourite album though…sigh.

Other general comments on the year…..

1998 to me was "the year the volume went up". Surely the first signs of the onset of maturity, when the noise in a nightclub or bar overwhelms one into cowering in the corner, quivering in terror. Or maybe it's just another symptom of that dreadful dance music scene. What puzzles me is that there's a whole generation of young people out there who have never chatted someone up, because they can't possibly hear one other in discos (or "clubs" as my trendy friends inform me they're called). So how DO they communicate their desires???! Maybe it's got something to do with how well one dances. If that is the case, I fear my genes are going to be bred out of existence as the Fred Astaires of the rave scene sweep all before them in a evolutionary orgy of dancing/mating. For once in my life, I feel I've got something in common with Phil Collins…

On a personal level, (not that I imagine anybody is even slightly interested in this, but that won't stop me) 1998 was also the year I discovered the joys of not having a television. So, as I never go to the cinema (except when abroad) my top 10 films of the year are:

1. The Butcher Boy (something patriotic within me stirred whilst on holiday in Vienna and I convinced myself to go see this. Thankfully it was sub-titled, not dubbed in German, so I almost enjoyed myself.)

2. Barb Wire (caught this while calling into a friend recently, and decided to hang around for it as the special effects were uplifting)

3. Whatever shite RTE are showing on Christmas Day as I try and remember all my neighbours' names and not fall asleep during the annual "there's fuckall happening in our house and someone finished off the last of the whiskey, so we're going to come over and bore the arses of yiz until yiz give us all your drink and we spill it all over your couch and our selves, whilst our kids eat all yer fucking sweets except the coffee ones which they'll give to our smelly fucking dog who'll vomit it up on your new shoes until you feel like screaming, but you can't fucking scream cos we're the neighbours and we'll tell every fucker in the parish that yeer a bunch of weirdos if anyone in this house so much as fucking blinks strangely, and that'll be the fucking end of yiz around here then. So it will. And good fucking riddance too yiz good for nottin tightarses and giz some more of that whiskey. Bastards." gettogether. Probably "Indiana Jones in Some Other Terrifying Edifice" or something.

And that's all the films I'll be seeing in 1998.

So, I guess I'm the wrong guy to be giving you top 10 films of the year.

And I'm probably the wrong guy to be giving you top 10 albums of the year considering my list contains only 1 album released in 1998.

Well, it's your own fault for asking. And if you wanted 1998 only releases you should've fucking said it.

Finally, for me 1998 was also the year illiteracy went into orbit. Rampant abuse of the English language by barely-simian buffoons with "have keyboard, must be a savant" attitudes. Let's take our time and learn to COMMUNICATE again folks. No more


> fyi……….

or
> pls rd b4 u fwd 2 yr …

or my (least) favourite
> thanx

However shoddy those Shakespearean sonnets seem, my own personal literary pet hate is directed towards the violent abuse I daily see laid at the feet of some of my favourite words. Not to dwell on the topic for too long, the two main victims must be "you're" and "it's" (alias "your" and "its" to the grammatical sinners).

No further evidence of any anal-retention on my part is necessary, I must agree, but I shall not rest from correcting these abhorrences of language where ever I espy them. So be warned!

So to sum my feelings on 1998: I wish it was 1994 again.

To quote Martin Hayes' only Morrissey quote: "this <insert generic post-modern cultural reference here> says nottin to me about my life."

On the bright side, at least we don't have to worry about the year 2000 bug for another 12 months. And we should all have our fortunes made by then scaring other people into giving us lots of money so we can make them feel better by pretending to worry about it for them, but inserting a no-guarantees clause into the contract.

And of course, the highlight of the year had to be playing Red House Painters' "Mistress" at a wedding and watching everyone run for cover. Thanks for that opportunity, Martin and Ann

e!
…my top 10 films of the year are:

1. The Butcher Boy (something patriotic within me stirred whilst on holiday in Vienna and I convinced myself to go see this. Thankfully it was sub-titled, not dubbed in German, so I almost enjoyed myself.)

2. Barb Wire (caught this while calling into a friend recently, and decided to hang around for it as the special effects were uplifting)

3. Whatever shite RTE are showing on Christmas Day as I try and remember all my neighbours' names and not fall asleep during the annual "there's fuckall happening in our house and someone finished off the last of the whiskey, so we're going to come over and bore the arses of yiz until yiz give us all your drink and we spill it all over your couch and our selves, whilst our kids eat all yer fucking sweets except the coffee ones which they'll give to our smelly fucking dog who'll vomit it up on your new shoes until you feel like screaming, but you can't fucking scream cos we're the neighbours and we'll tell every fucker in the parish that yeer a bunch of weirdos if anyone in this house so much as fucking blinks strangely, and that'll be the fucking end of yiz around here then. So it will. And good fucking riddance too yiz good for nottin tightarses and giz some more of that whiskey. Bastards." gettogether. Probably "Indiana Jones in Some Other Terrifying Edifice" or something.

Here's my top 10:

1. Scud Mountain Boys - The Early Years
2. Ron Sexsmith - Other Songs
3. Scud Mountain Boys - Massachusetts
4. Red House Painters - Ocean Beach
5. Sophia - Fixed Water
6. David Gray - Flesh
7. Low - The Curtain Hits The Cast
8. Seam - Are You Driving Me Crazy?
9. Michael Nyman - Live
10. Jeff Buckley - Sketches For My Sweetheart The Drunk

top

Martin Hayes

Top 10 1998

1. Other Songs - Ron Sexsmith
2. Smitten - Buffalo Tom
3. Good Morning Spider -Sparklehorse
4. White Magic for Lovers - Drugstore
5. Mermaid Avenue - Wilco & Billy Bragg
6. The Boy with the Arab Strap - Belle & Sebastian
7. White Ladder - David Gray
8. International Velvet - Catatonia
9. Up - REM
10. Without you I'm Nothing - Placebo

Honorable Mentions
Deserter's Songs - Mercury Rev
Mezzanine - Massive Attack
Fin de Siecle - Divine Comedy

Singles
Brimful of Asha - Norman Cook/Cornershop
Road Rage - Catatonia
Postcard - Buffalo Tom
El President - Drugstore

Gigs
Ron Sexsmith - Olympia
Dom Irrera - Limerick
Mark Doherty - Kilkenny
Echo & the Bunnymen - Olympia
Dylan Moran - Kilkenny
David Gray - Limerick
Tommy Tiernan - Limerick

Cover of the year
David Gray's 9 minute interpretation of Soft Cell's Say Hello Wave Goodbye. Bliss.

Films
1. The Big Lebowski
2. Out of Sight
3. Ronin
4. The Spanish Prisoner
5. The General

Worst
Something about Mary
Blade

top

Lucas Hilbert

1. Massive Attack - Mezzanine
2. Tortoise - TNT
3. Arto Lindsay - Noon Chill
4. Mogwai - Young Team
5. Elliott Smith - XO
6. Whiskeytown - Strangers Almanac
7. Swervedriver - 99th Dream
8. Remy Zero - Villa Elaine
9. Jeff Buckley - Sketches
10. Pulp - This Is Hardcore

top

Niall Lynch

Albums

1. Belle & Sebastian - The Boy with the Arab Strap
2. Cornelius - Fantasma
3. Hayden - The Closer I get
4. PJ Harvey - Is This Desire?
5. Arab Strap - Philophobia
6. Jay Jay Johanson - Whiskey
7. Air - Moon Safari
8. Jeff Buckley - My Sweetheart the Drunk
9. Mark Eitzel - I'm Caught in a Trap and I can't back out because I love you too much, baby
10. Craig Armstrong - The Space Between us

top

Kevin McGrath

1 - Jeff Buckley - Grace
2 - Air - Moon Safari
3 - Lou Reed - Transformer
4 - REM - Document
5 - Spiritualized - Ladies and Gents, we are floating in space
6 - Radiohead - OK Computer
7 - Aphex Twin - Selected Ambient Works 85-92
8 - Leftfield - Leftism
9 - U2 Pop
10 - The Divine Comedy - A Short Album About Love

top

Dave McGuinness

1. Bob Dylan - Live 1966
2. Miles Davis - Kind of Blue
3. DJ Shadow - Endtroducing
4. Billy Bragg / Wilco - Mermaid Avenue
5. REM - Up
6. Air - Moon Safari
7. Painted from Memory - Elvis Costello / Burt Bacharach
8. Manic Street Preachers - This is my truth, tell me yours
9. Smashing Pumpkins - Adore
10. Alpha - Come from Heaven

HM's
Gomez - Bring it on
Finley Quaye - Maverick A Strike
Katell Keineg - Jet
U.N.K.L.E. - Psyence fiction

top

Ray McNamara

I am going to take your request literally and name the top 10 albums I listened to for the first time in 1998. I don't think its been a very good year so I'm afraid there is a lot of old stuff in it.


1) Mercury Rev - "Deserter's Songs"
2) Beastie Boys - "Hello Nasty"
3) Radiohead - "Airbag/How Am I Driving"
4) David Gray - "White Ladder"
5) Asian Dub Foundation - "Rafi's Revenge"
6) Dandy Warhols - "The Dandy Warhols Come Down"
7) Fatboy Slim - "You've Come A Long Way Baby"
8) The Rolling Stones - "Exile On Main Street"
9) De La Soul - "3 Feet High And Rising"
10) Oasis - "The Masterplan"

top

Breanndán Ó Nualláin

I'm not quite sure how I got on this list but it's certainly a good way to look back over one's musical year so I'll bite.

I'm not big on scoring points and all that. When it comes down to it, how do you compare Hole with Belle & Sebastian? So my Top 10 in some kind of rough order are these:

Gomez. Bring it on.
Lemonator. Lemonator.
Belle & Sebastian. The Boy with the Arab Strap.
Hole. Celebrity Skin.
Pedro the Lion. It's Hard to Find a Friend.
Zita Swoon. I Paint Pictures on a Wedding Dress.
Billy Bragg & Wilco. Mermaid Avenue.
Soul Coughing. El Oso.
Cake. Prolonging the magic.
Nuff Said. Red.

In my view, a list is more fun with an explanation so here's mine If you aren't interested in my waffle, skip through it to my favourite gigs at the bottom:

Finnish band. Power pop as it should be. Happy music that you can jump around to.

Gomez. Bring it on.

At one point I had put 98 down for a total write-off in terms of new bands; the worst on record. Then this surfaced in May and things got better after that. One trend I've noticed this year is to write very little on your CD sleeve so it took a while before I knew anything about this band. As a result, the atmosphere of this album had me convinced that these guys were from Arizona or somewhere around there before I discovered they're actually from somewhere near Liverpool. They also played one of the best gigs I saw this year to several dozen people. Only their second gig outside England, they said endearingly.

Soul Coughing. El Oso.
Cake. Prolonging the magic.

The dance department. Both of these bands have such particular styles that I thought that they'd get old very quickly but they both keep coming up with excellent new material. Soul Coughing take the best out of drums'n'bass and play it like it should be played: with drums and a bass, not with a damned computer. And as for Cake, he may be arrogant git with a rickety acoustic guitar, but he can bring a swing to your hips and a smile to your face.

Hole. Celebrity Skin.

Grunge lives. Great album. So this is the secret to making a great guitar music album? Sleep with a fair cross-section of the main exponents of the art over the last decade? Apologies for the cynicism but the Broomfield documentary and every interview I've seen with her this year have convinced me that Courtney Love is evil. Great album nonetheless.

Nuff Said. Red.

Dutch band that ranges from the Beach Boys to Tears for Fears to outright speed metal. Not deep but great fun. Excellent music to cook by.

Billy Bragg & Wilco. Mermaid Avenue.

Who would have thought to approach Billy Bragg with this project? And what a humbling task for him to take on. And what a beautiful result. You can feel Guthrie in the music.

Belle & Sebastian. The Boy with the Arab Strap.
Beautifully fragile.
Pedro the Lion. It's Hard to Find a Friend.

A couple of weeks ago I walked into my friendly neighbourhood record shop and this was playing and I liked it so I bought it. Another one of those sparse CD covers so I still know nothing about who or what it is. But there are some very beautiful songs here. 'Big trucks' could have been written by Harry Chapin and it'll probably get played to death on the radio if anyone discovers it. And what about 'Of minor prophets and their prostitute wives' for a song title?

Zita Swoon. I Paint Pictures on a Wedding Dress.

Belgian band centred around Stef Kamil Carlens formerly of dEUS. Used to be called Moondog Jr. Quirky, honky-tonk, carnivalesque music with a soul. Carlens is one of those people who lays himself bare in his music.

That was the ten.

As for gigs, I'll start at the bottom and work up. Cornershop (The Max, Amsterdam) was the worst gig of the year bar none. It's hard to imagine such a wooden performance to such groovy music.

In the 'missed it the first time around' category was Cheap Trick (The Max). Yeah, cheap and trashy, but they still rock.

In the 'last time around' category, although he denies it vehemently was Ian Dury and the lockheads. When anyone else would throw in the towel and retire to the Sunny Days convalescent home, our Ian does a Blues Brothers on it and gets the band on the road again. Brilliant musicians to a man.

In the 'never did get around to that one before' category was the Rolling Stones in Het Malieveld in the Hague. It pissed down the whole time and we hardly noticed.

The Divine Comedy were both divine and comical in the Milky Way in Amsterdam. For one reason or another I still haven't got their new album but I suspect it would have made my top ten.

Soul Coughing (Milky Way) and Cake (Max) are great bands for a swingin' night out. Say no more.

I don't quite understand why The Manic Street Preachers are rated as 'the most important British band' of the moment by some of the British music comics but there's no doubt that they're a powerful live band. Their Paradiso gig was stupendous.

I'm a big fan of the Posies who unfortunately called it a day this year. But not before I saw them a couple of times when they toured the Netherlands and once in Tavastiaklubbi in Helsinki, of all places.

Belle & Sebastian in Paradiso was delicate, ethereal, fragile, fey, twee… Get out the thesaurus on this one.

But the concert of the year for me and, frankly, I don't think I've ever seen a better concert was Radiohead at Radio City Music Hall in New York. I must have seen easily a thousand concerts by now but I've never experienced such acoustics and sound quality. Every shade of every note played was audible. But aside from the technical stuff, Radiohead were absolutely majestic. They soared. Awesome, in the truest sense of the word.

(Now why oh why wasn't there a category this year for Most Amusing Unzipping of the year? I'm sure George Michael would have won it over Bill Clinton by a short, eh, head.)

top

Caroline O'Reilly

Albums

1. 'is this desire' pj harvey
2. 'my sweetheart the drunk' jeff buckley
3. 'the boy with the arab strap - belle+sebastian
4. sushi 4004
5. 'one love' delakota
6. 'young team' mogwai
7. 'take off and landing' yoshinori sunahara
8. 'xo' elliot smith
9. 'the sky is too high' graham coxon
10. 'mutations' beck

top